Recipe for cake NOTE: the following directions makes EACH tier, not both. You will need to make two batches to make both the bottom (8×3) and top tier (6×3) of the cake)
1/2 cup unsalted butter, softened
1 1/2 cups sugar
2 large eggs, room temperature
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1 oz. liquid red food coloring + 1 bottleful of water
Beat butter and sugar in a stand mixer on medium speed until fluffy. Add one egg at a time allowing to mix for 15-20 seconds after each addition to ensure it is fully incorporated. In a small bowl combine vanilla extract, cocoa powder, red food coloring and 1 oz water until smooth and mix into cake batter, making sure to scrape down the side of the bowl and mix very well.
In a separate bowl sift together flour, baking powder and salt and set aside.
Turn mixer on medium and add the flour mixture in three additions while alternating between the buttermilk, starting and ending with the flour mixture.
Combine baking soda and vinegar in a small cup, allowing it to fizz, and add to batter once it settles.
Make two batches of the recipe and add one to an 8×3″ prepared cake pan and one to a 6×3 prepared cake pan and bake for 40-45 minutes and 50-55 minutes, respectively, or until a toothpick can be inserted and comes out clean.
Once cooled, level off the top of the cakes with a knife or cake leveler so it is nice and flat.
For the frosting:
Beat butter in a stand mixer over medium speed until light and fluffy and add confectioners’ one cup at a time, scraping down the sides and mixing until fully incorporated.
For the assembly:
Frost each cake tier completely using all of the frosting except for two tbsp, making sure the frosting is smooth and even. Place in fridge for 15 minutes to chill slightly.
Split fondant and place on a surface dusted with corn starch or powdered sugar. Roll out to 1/8 inch thickness and place on each cake. Ensure your fondant is big enough to cover the entire cake and its sides!
Smooth fondant around the cake sides slowly, working down each side and smoothing as you go along. Place each tier in fridge for 15 minutes to chill.
Once chilled, place one tablespoons of frosting directly into the center of the bottom tier, but do not spread. Place top tier on the bottom tier and use remaining tablespoon of frosting to patch up any gaps between the bottom and top tier.
For the “blood”:
Combine all ingredients and mix well. The chocolate or maple syrup and green food coloring will ensure the color of the mixture has a more realistic veinous blood look. Adjust water and cornstarch if too thick/runny and adjust food coloring if the coloring is off.
Directions: Place cake outside on top of newspaper to ensure you do not make a mess. Cover hands in shortening or wear gloves.
Dip toothbrush or vegetable brush in the prepared blood and use your finger to run across the brush while close to the cake to create a blood spray effect. Dip brush in blood and flick it at the cake to create a blood splatter effect.
That is so beautiful. I might make it for a non-halloween style dinner and maybe tone down to splatter.
I wonder. When I use those deep cake pans I have two problems. (1). I have to cook them so long to get the inside cooked that they are brown around the edges and (2). They sort of puff up and aren’t level and flat on top like your beautiful photogenic ones.
Are you trimming them? Are you slicing the bulging tops off? What do you think I might be doing wrong?
Hi Margot! You could easily make this into an any-time-of-the-year dessert. The blood might look weird on a Thanksgiving or Presidents Day cake, but hey, I say go for it!
To address the problems that come up:
1) I noticed very little by way of browning on these cakes by baking them at 350. But if there’s a significant amount you can scrape or cut it off, but it shouldn’t be too bad that it ruins the consistency, moistness or flavor. It’s important to make sure they don’t over-bake though, otherwise it’ll dry out pretty quickly.
2) I level off the part of the cake that bulges out of the pan, but I should’ve put that in the instructions After I level off that part, I actually use the section I leveled off as the bottom of the cake, that way the top is the perfectly rounded off side.
I don’t even know why I typed that. It’s a terrible pun. I could delete it, but I’m kind of lazy so I don’t even want to hit the backspace key, so it stays.
I find this strangely appealing and have lately become more and more interested in food images that are less cute and pretty and more controversial? I know I’m reading a lot into it here, it’s still cake, but this is my roundabout way of saying, this is totally awesome! Perfect for this time of year for both Hallowe’en and the new season of Dexter.
Thanks, Melanie! I really wanted to create something that wasn’t cutesy, which is what a lot of Halloween recipes have become. I like the dark and macabre side of Halloween, and I’m glad you appreciate that aspect of it as well!
AND I AM SO EXCITED ABOUT THIS NEW SEASON OF DEXTER I CAN’T EVEN STOP WRITING IN CAPS.
I did slightly different version of it and I gave a link to your recipe/website on my blog. It turned out really delicious and moist. Thanks for huge inspiration and happy Halloween!
Love this! I’ve made red velvet cakes, brownies, cup cakes, cake balls but never one like this! Interesting & kind of yucky technique for the blood splatter. I’ll have to decide whose birthday, wedding shower, etc to spring it on…
31 Comments
Gorgeous & brilliant, I love it!!!
Thank you, Gina! You’re awesome!
A terrific seasonal twist on an old favorite!
Thank you, Renee! Just the right amount of creepy and delicious
I love this idea! I will definitely be making for Halloween.
Definitely let me know if you make it!
http://finedininglovers.com/blog/news-trends/scary-cakes-pathology-museum/
Love it! Such a great twist to add to this Halloween season!!!
Thanks, Dee
Genius
Thanks, Matt!
My favorite cake combined with my favorite holiday!!! Kerry you are a genius and I must make this
Love the story to go along with it, very entertaining.
I knew you’d like it, I remember you saying how much you like red velvet!
WOW, what a gorgeous and yet devilish cake! Great job, I love it!!
Thank you, Lauren! It’s a little bit macabre, but it wouldn’t be Halloweeny without a little blood, right?
That is so beautiful. I might make it for a non-halloween style dinner and maybe tone down to splatter.
I wonder. When I use those deep cake pans I have two problems. (1). I have to cook them so long to get the inside cooked that they are brown around the edges and (2). They sort of puff up and aren’t level and flat on top like your beautiful photogenic ones.
Are you trimming them? Are you slicing the bulging tops off? What do you think I might be doing wrong?
Hi Margot! You could easily make this into an any-time-of-the-year dessert. The blood might look weird on a Thanksgiving or Presidents Day cake, but hey, I say go for it!
To address the problems that come up:
1) I noticed very little by way of browning on these cakes by baking them at 350. But if there’s a significant amount you can scrape or cut it off, but it shouldn’t be too bad that it ruins the consistency, moistness or flavor. It’s important to make sure they don’t over-bake though, otherwise it’ll dry out pretty quickly.
2) I level off the part of the cake that bulges out of the pan, but I should’ve put that in the instructions
After I level off that part, I actually use the section I leveled off as the bottom of the cake, that way the top is the perfectly rounded off side.
Brilliant, Kerry, you are brilliant! YUMM….and also yikes!
xoxo
Cheri
Thanks, Cheri!
Would you say I’m…bloody brilliant?
I don’t even know why I typed that. It’s a terrible pun. I could delete it, but I’m kind of lazy so I don’t even want to hit the backspace key, so it stays.
In all of its unfunny glory.
I find this strangely appealing and have lately become more and more interested in food images that are less cute and pretty and more controversial? I know I’m reading a lot into it here, it’s still cake, but this is my roundabout way of saying, this is totally awesome! Perfect for this time of year for both Hallowe’en and the new season of Dexter.
Thanks, Melanie! I really wanted to create something that wasn’t cutesy, which is what a lot of Halloween recipes have become. I like the dark and macabre side of Halloween, and I’m glad you appreciate that aspect of it as well!
AND I AM SO EXCITED ABOUT THIS NEW SEASON OF DEXTER I CAN’T EVEN STOP WRITING IN CAPS.
amazing, funny, stylish …. just great
This is the coolest cake I’ve ever seen. We don’t really celebrate Halloween in Poland that much, but I don’t care, I’m gonna make this cake
Amazing cake and amazing photography…I am from Poland too luckily we are in dublin so looking for inspiration and thank you for inspiring us!
Thanks so much! Let me know if you end up making it!
I did slightly different version of it and I gave a link to your recipe/website on my blog. It turned out really delicious and moist. Thanks for huge inspiration and happy Halloween!
I love it! It turned out so great, and glad it worked so well for you. Happy Halloween!
Can you just tell me what is the temperature for baking cakes?
350 as long as you aren’t at a super high altitude
Love this! I’ve made red velvet cakes, brownies, cup cakes, cake balls but never one like this! Interesting & kind of yucky technique for the blood splatter. I’ll have to decide whose birthday, wedding shower, etc to spring it on…
Red velvet is the best kind of cake, isn’t it?